Buffalo Bar & Grill

1st, I love the atmosphere of this place. Old guys at the bar in cowboy hats. 2nd, service is top notch. Its noticeable how good it is for sure. Everything we ate was excellent. Such a unique place. Loved it

Great experience here for dinner tonight! Found this place when my family and I were starving after hiking Tonto Natural Bridge. Upon walking in around 6 pm, this place was packed! There were a few tables left and we sat ourselves at a booth. The server came to greet us very quickly — she took our drink and food orders at the same time without writing anything down. Our food came out accurately and hot and fresh! I ordered a regular cheeseburger with French fries, my daughter ordered a plain burger with fries and her dad had a green chile burger with fries. All of our food was delicious and exceeded our expectations. For dessert, we shared the cookie with ice cream and chocolate drizzle — definitely a good portion for three! Service was excellent despite it being busy and prices were fair. We will absolutely be back!

Good local community feeling to it. Sat outside because the seats I wanted were taken by a huge party. It was just the right temperature. Any colder and they would need some outdoor heating units. Service was prompt and fast, older woman working was a boss just getting things done. Water and everything was promptly delivered to the table along with a grilled cheese and fries for $10. Tasted homemade. The fries were of good quality, tasted almost like Arby's curly fries, I recommend. Good ketchup, good water, good experience. Local down to earth feeling and environment... it is a bar so keep that in mind. Good mixture of crowd age, mostly older folks wanting a relaxing meal and drink.

This is a great place to bring the family, date or friends. I really enjoyed my green Chile burger with sweet potatoes fries and my friend really enjoyed her hot pastrami club. The B52 coffees were awesome!! So delicious. The customer service was great! The hometown atmosphere and decor is very inviting also. We would definitely go back.

We both had delicious burgers. The staff was upbeat. The bar is clearly a locals hangout and has a fun atmosphere. Overheard a few funny stories from folks that had known each other their whole lives. Will definitely go back if we come this way again. Thanks for the great food.

The fried fish was really good, sweet potato fries even better. Cocktails were very tasty and the service was outstanding. And I love this western vibe. Reminds me of old West Colorado or a saloon type atmosphere.

Very friendly staff offered prompt and awesome service! Cozy, good place to watch the Sunday football games. Food orders arrived quickly. We all ordered different burgers, with various sides (onion rings, waffle fries, regular fries); all sides were great. Burgers were average; the patty itself didn't have much flavor. I would go here again and try something different, as they have a large menu and the service was great, with a comfortable atmosphere.

This was our 2nd visit and, AGAIN, we had a delicious meal and fast and courteous service. This is our new go-to when driving into Payson. An added bonus is the adjoining parking lot will accommodate a 36 foot motor home with a tow car, and it's easy to get in and out.